"According to them, somebody with my name in Washington, D.C. won the lottery and failed to report it."
That is Ashley Pitter, a mother of four, describing a letter from the Social Security Administration. Three of her children are eligible for SSI. She says the letters also claimed bank accounts and stock futures she does not have. On a phone call about an overpayment, she says a man from the agency told her she had all the time at home to sit around and read the book. She hung up.
She agreed to sit down with me and be named, because she wanted this story heard. What follows is her account, as she told it in this episode. It is not a ruling on her case, and it is not legal advice.
- Ashley Pitter, a parent of four, has three children eligible for SSI. Benefits started in 2022. In 2024 she got a call about an overpayment.
- She says she called to report income the first month and was told she did not have to call every month if her husband's pay stayed the same.
- She says the agency later told her the income figure came from Equifax, and that the figure was wrong.
- Letters, as she describes them, claimed a lottery win in Washington, D.C., extra bank accounts, and stock futures. She says none of that is true.
- She describes 41-page letters, an overpayment they put at more than $7,000 over two years, and $100 a month already being deducted while an appeal is pending.
- In her account, SSI is also the door to Medicaid. Losing it would mean choosing which care to keep.
- She describes a $2,000 resource limit, and an 11-year-old car counted in a way that put them over.
- The change she is asking for starts with this: if you will not hand her a check, pay for the actual services. And listen.
- This is her story as she told it. It is not a finding about her case, and it is not legal or benefits advice.
If you are holding the benefits paperwork, the waitlists, and the therapy schedule at the same time, we can lay the week out together. Book a 45-minute family care mapping call
I am a BCBA, but I am not your BCBA. This is general education, not treatment, not legal advice, and not benefits advice. It is not a treatment recommendation for your child or your state, and it is not a ruling on anyone's SSI case. Build the real plan with the people who actually treat your child, and get legal or benefits help from someone qualified to give it.
The phone call and the letter
Ashley Pitter is a mother of four. Three of her children are currently eligible for SSI. The benefits, she says, first started in 2022. About two years later, in 2024, she got a phone call from a man who said he was with the Social Security Administration. They were facing an overpayment. She had never heard of it. He asked whether she had gotten the letter about the call. She had not.
He told her that since the family began getting SSI, they had been failing to report income. She was floored, she says, for several reasons. As a new recipient, she had called the first month to report income. The employee she spoke with, as she tells it, said she did not have to call every month if her husband's pay stayed the same. Call if there was an increase or a decrease, if cash fell from the sky, if someone got a new job. His salary, she says, never changed. So that is what she did.
Almost two years later, on that call, she told the man what she had been told. His response, as she recounts it, was: "Ma'am, you have that book and you have all the time at home to sit around. I suggest you read it." She hung up. The letter about the call arrived two days later, after the call had already happened.
The income she says he never earned
When she did get through to the office, she says she was told the overpayment happened because her husband's income was too high. She asked where they had gotten that figure. The answer she says she was given was Equifax.
She called Equifax. As she tells it, they had him making an amount that did not match what he earned, and she had to untangle that before the SSI office would even keep talking to her about it. She appealed. At the time we spoke, she was still waiting on a decision. The overpayment call was in 2024. She had been waiting, she said, for years, with 2027 almost in view.
Then more letters arrived. A second overpayment. Letters that, as she describes them, claimed six bank accounts when the family had three. And the line that opens this episode: according to them, somebody with her name in Washington, D.C. won the lottery and failed to report it. They also claimed, she says, that she had bank accounts with Stanley and Morgan and owned a lot of stock futures. "Do you?" I asked. "I do not."
A 41-page letter, and another, and another
In her most recent letter, she says, there were 41 pages informing her of overpayments for one child. The same day, she says, she received 41-page letters for her other two children who receive SSI. That was not even the full appeal, as she understood it. It was the request to have the decision looked at again.
What were the letters claiming? As she tells it, an overpayment of more than $7,000 over a two-year period, or about $200 a month. One letter, she says, also told her they had paid $902 when they should have paid $943, so they owed her money in one place while collecting it in another.
And while the appeal was pending, she says they told her they were going to start deducting $100 from the amount the family received every month. If the appeal went in her favor, they would give the money back. As she put it, what sense does that make?
She also describes a March letter that treated a tax refund as income, even after she says she showed them the money came from a refund, more than once, in more than one March. Still not fixed, she says.
You should not have to carry the letters, the appeals, and the care schedule alone. Book a 45-minute call
What the check is actually covering
For this family, SSI is not an abstract government line item. She says it is also the door to Medicaid. If the SSI goes away, the Medicaid goes with it. Then she would have to choose which care to keep.
She walks through the copays as they stand today. All four children go to speech, at $30 a visit, or $120 for speech alone. Occupational therapy, another $120 a week in copays. ABA comes at least three days a week for three of the children, at $90 a day, paid out of pocket, because it has been hard, she says, to find in-home ABA providers who take Medicaid. She also says she has met a $5,000 deductible by March every single year.
This is the part I want people to hear clearly. The fight she is in is not about a luxury. It is about whether the services that let her children communicate, learn, and get through a week stay in place.
The $2,000 rule and the car
SSI has a resource limit. As she states it, and as the program rules have stood for a long time, you cannot have more than $2,000 in countable resources for an eligible individual. She describes an 11-year-old car that, in their paperwork, was still valued at $2,400, and that, together with the loan, put them over the resource limit for one child. The car, she says, was treated as if it were cash in the bank. It is a car that costs money to keep, including, as she tells it, a payment of about $500 a month.
She also applied for her fourth child, she says, 16 months before we spoke, and was still waiting. In the meantime, as she understands the paperwork, an applying child can be listed in a way that starts reducing what the children who are already eligible receive.
I am not the Social Security Administration, and I am not her lawyer. I am telling you what she said happened to her family, because she asked for the story to be heard.
There is no I anymore
"There is no I anymore," she says. "I'm just mommy. And mommy's on call 24-7."
She describes days that run from therapy to therapy, and evenings that start with a panic about dinner. She cancels her own dentist appointments and her own follow-ups. She had not had an annual doctor's appointment for herself in about two years, she says, because the calendar is for them, and they come first.
What she wants, as she puts it, is a moment where she can just focus on her child without thinking about the 41-page letter sitting on the desk. Did I fill out the application on time? Did I collect all the documentation, again? What am I forgetting? There is not a single day, she says, when they are not at a therapist or a doctor's office, and she has other children at home who need her too.
The change she wants
I asked her what she would change. She started with income limits for SSI. When you have a child with disabilities, she says, pay for the speech therapy. Pay for the ABA. "If you don't want to hand me a check because you think I'm out here playing the lottery and swimming in money, fine. Just pay for the actual services."
She also asked for more services in the public schools, so a child is not pushed out of the free public education she is supposed to have. "SSI needs to run the same way," she says. "What can you give her to actually help and not hurt?"
And she asked, if nothing else, to be listened to. Every interaction, she says, whether in person or on the phone, sticks to the same script: your payment went down because you made too much money last month. "But I didn't make too much money. That's what I'm trying to explain to you if you took the time to listen."
Her first ask, at the top of the episode, is simple, and it is not about a check. "Yes, I'm asking for the ability for her to talk."
Next step
You should not have to hold all of this by yourself
On a 45-minute family care mapping call, we look at your child's providers, appointments, and paperwork, and where all of that is landing on you, so you can see your next steps.
Book a 45-minute family care mapping callTell me in the comments: If you have ever gotten a benefits letter that did not describe your actual life, what did it get wrong?
Sources
- Social Security Administration, resolving an overpayment
- Social Security Administration, SSI resources (including the $2,000 / $3,000 limits)
- Social Security Administration, appealing a decision
Events, figures, and quotes are as stated in the episode, in Ashley Pitter's own account. Official SSA pages are linked for general program rules, not as a judgment of her case.
Next step
Want help while you wait?
Want help while you wait, plus a community of parents working through this together? You can start with a free family packet, and book a call above whenever you like.
Get a free family packetAshleigh Dominguez, MS, BCBA, is a Board Certified Behavior Analyst licensed in North Carolina, Georgia, and Iowa. This article is general education based on the episode. It is not clinical advice, not treatment, not legal advice, and not a treatment recommendation for your child or your state. Ashleigh is not your BCBA and has not met your family. Please build your real plan with the providers who know your child.